A toy supplier sends you a wholesale application. Its website also has a Faire link. You can buy from the same business either way, so which order button should you use?
The answer may change between an opening order and a reorder. Comparing Faire vs direct wholesale means checking the terms attached to the purchase: when payment is due, which merchandise can be returned, what shipping costs, and who handles a problem.
Toysmith’s wholesale page offers both Faire ordering and an application for direct accounts. It illustrates an important distinction: you may be choosing two ways to order from one supplier, rather than choosing between different suppliers.
Table of Contents
Start With the Same Order, Not Two Different Carts
Before comparing prices, make sure both routes cover the same item numbers, quantities, assortment, and packaging. A display containing mixed colors is not equivalent to a case of individually selected designs just because both contain 24 toys.
For squishy toys, check the size and construction as well. A familiar shape can appear in several versions, and a product photograph may not explain the difference.
Our mixed-SKU squishy toy wholesale guide discusses assortment breakdowns. Use those details to build one order list for comparing both options.
Then check account access. A marketplace login does not automatically create an approved direct account with the supplier. Toysmith, for example, states that new direct accounts require an application and approval.
Our toy wholesale account application requirements guide explains the information buyers may need to prepare. Confirm the requirements with the supplier you plan to order from.
A Faire vs direct wholesale comparison becomes useful only when both options are available to your business and cover equivalent merchandise.
An Opening-Order Return Is Not a Standing Safety Net
Faire’s retailer return guidance says eligible first orders with each brand can be returned, typically within 60 days. The window can vary, so check the deadline shown in your account. Later orders with that brand do not receive the same opening-order return eligibility, even when you try products you have not purchased before.
That matters for a toy store testing a new line. An eligible opening order may offer flexibility that the supplier’s direct terms do not. Confirm eligibility and product exclusions before relying on that benefit.
Original outbound shipping and duties or import taxes are not refundable under Faire’s stated return guidance. Covered return shipping therefore does not make an unsuccessful product trial cost-free.
For direct orders, ask for the supplier’s written policy on unsold merchandise. Keep that separate from claims for damaged, incorrect, or missing goods; those are different problems.
When weighing Faire vs direct wholesale, ask what happens if the toys arrive correctly but do not sell. Then ask what happens if they arrive incorrectly. One policy may not answer both.
Payment terms deserve the same attention. Faire offers Net 60 to eligible, approved retailers; it is not automatic for every account. Check the actual invoice due date rather than assuming payment falls due 60 days after delivery.
A direct supplier may offer different terms, require payment before shipment, or review credit separately. Compare the terms approved for your account.
Compare the Order You Will Receive and Pay For
Illustrative example: A retailer is considering the same 48-piece squishy order through two routes. One checkout displays a first-order promotion; the other quote includes a different freight allowance. Neither headline gives the buyer enough information to choose.
Put the offers beside each other:
| Question | What needs to match or be explained |
|---|---|
| Merchandise | Item numbers, versions, quantity, and assortment |
| Amount payable | Product total, discounts, freight, and applicable charges |
| Payment | Charge timing and the actual invoice due date |
| Availability | Confirmed stock, expected ship date, and partial shipments |
| Returns | Eligible merchandise, deadline, exclusions, and costs that remain payable |
| Order problems | Contact, reporting deadline, and evidence required |
For Faire vs direct wholesale, this is more informative than comparing a unit price with a promotional banner.
Ask whether the catalog and availability differ by route. Do not assume a direct account provides every item, a lower minimum, or better stock. Likewise, verify the expected ship date and delivery estimate before treating an online order as inventory that will arrive in time for an event.
Record the opening-order offer separately from the terms expected on the next purchase. A one-time incentive can make a trial attractive without making the same route preferable for every replenishment.
The Faire vs direct wholesale decision belongs to the order in front of you. Choose the route whose confirmed costs, timing, and protections fit that purchase, then revisit the comparison when the order changes.
Read More